It's just relative to all the hype he gets. He's very good, but People calling him a superstar, best young PG in the league, Voted Allstar starter, so many ads and billboards etc which I believe makes him very overrated for what he produces right now. Obviously the cavs are terrible in all areas, but he really does not make his teammates better at all, I can understand if he isn't the most popular teammate.
one of the key elements i look for in a player is character...Irving is not a player I want around
For all his foibles Kyle makes his team better. Can't say the same thing for Kyrie. I honestly think Wall and Lowry are better PGs than Irving.
omfg who is better than kyrie irving that he's overrated?
you kids need to look up the meanings of these big words you're throwing around.
wait don't tell me. kyle lowry is better than kyrie irving right? ROFL i don't even have the words.
Irving is a hell of a scorer but not, and I am sure he won't become a point guard. Yes he puts up stats, but they haven't got any better since drafting him. This leads me to believe he is a me guy, that believes he should be part of a big three. Especially when he is talking of leaving so early in his career. Winning never just happens, you have to work for it, and loose to get there. But he doesn't make anyone around him better. Even the boys on TNT say the same thing. How can u be there and not make anyone better. He looks for his shot way to often, yes he gets his assists but not before he puts up his shots. Point guards lead and dictate tempo. The great ones do anyway and it all starts and ends with them. He is not a leader that way, just a stat stuffer, that is shot first and not pass. I beg to differ for him even making the all-star game based on performance of his team. Yes the points are nice, but they haven't won like 25 games since drafting him. So in reality he is another score first guard, not a point guard. If we can get him he is only worth it if he can change his game to become a Point Guard. And judging from his previous 3 seasons, he is not doing that just looking to score more.
It would appear that a weak locker room, insane hype, and poor coaching/management has caused him to become a little bit of a knob. Also the constant feud between him and Waiters is not helping the environment.
If I was Cleveland I would look to trade Waiters and hire Charles Oakley as an assistant coach.
I tried to watch the Cavs/Knicks game last night and made it to half before turning it off. Absolutely awful basketball to watch.
What I don't understand about Kyrie is, why is he so easy to defend at times? First 5 mins of the game he barely touched the ball. Then when he does get it, he basically gets shut down by the dynamic defence of Raymond "don't call me fat" Felton, and Pablo "pass the walking stick" Prigioni. How does a young athletic guard get stopped by two slow guards? How does he manage to dribble into their double team then throw the ball away when he realizes he is in trouble?
Kyrie is talented and certainly would be better with more talent around him but he seems to have a sort of tunnel vision.
At this point, Lowry is the better player.
I'm 100 percent right 9.090909090909090 percent of the time
Heir, Prince of Cambridge
People need to start looking at Mike Brown a little harder, dude is the absolute worst. He's abysmal at developing young talent and Bennett is the perfect example front row center. While i don't think he should have been the #1 overall pick, he IS a talented player with a lot of potential and that jackass is straight ruining him.
But Irving also had Byron Scott for 2 years. Scott is not a bad coach (nor do I think he's the greatest or anything). And he's had success with PGs, including a young Chris Paul.
Management has definitely been the biggest problem in Cleveland, as it was totally stupid to bring back Mike Brown and they've made questionable player moves.
But I still don't like what I've seen from Irving. I don't think he's toxic or anything, but I haven't seen traits that I look for in a lead guard, especially with his talent level. I don't see leadership. I don't see a strong competitive edge. His ability to get other involved and run the O seems to have been stalled since he came into the league. I don't see the right effort level or attention to detail. And I don't want Toronto to be the team to try and figure out if he can change those things, especially given his likely future cost and apparent fragility.
For most overrated PG i'm going with Deron Williams
All the talent in the world but dude's a maroon
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)