Can we stop blaming the coach, please? It's simply not true that it's the coaches that tell Bargnani to stay out by the 3 point line. Bargnani is simply more comfortable there. And your excuse only makes sense in regards to offensive rebounding. Maybe you could explain why someone like Troy Murphy, who actually took MORE 3 point shots despite playing 8 fewer games, was able to finish 7th in the league in rebounding despite being parked out at the 3 point line?
Only five teams gave up MORE offensive rebounds than the Raptors. What that means is that, no matter what the opposing team was shooting, the Raptors were still giving more rebounds to the other team than most of the rest of the league. There were clearly plenty of rebounds available for the Raptors to grab, but they allowed the opposing team to grab them instead. And those rebounds that were available were on the defensive end for the Raptors. In other words, there's absolutely no excuse why Bargnani didn't grab more of them.
Have I ever blamed Bargnani solely for the poor defense? No, so please don't pretend that I have. He is, however, a big part of the problem. You can make up as many excuses as you want as to WHY he is such a poor team defender, but the fact remains that he is. He doesn't look any better when he plays with better defensive players. You just have to watch him to realize that he simply doesn't understand how to play team defense. He's not the only one who does things wrong, but he consistently makes bad plays on defense, and that simply can't be blamed on anyone else. If Bargnani were making good defensive decisions out there, but being asked to do too much because of other players playing bad defense, I could easily excuse this. But he's making bad decisions out there consistently, which makes a inadequate defense look even worse.
I have a lot of fire because I find it appalling that people continually overlook or make excuses for his fatal flaws. Fatal flaws which will prevent the team from ever excelling while he's a big part of it. If people wouldn't constantly make excuses for Bargnani I wouldn't constantly have to poke holes in the validity of those excuses.
I don't ever start threads about Bargnani. I almost never bring him up. I'm well aware of my reputation on here. The fact that you don't feel that Bargnani deserves criticism is exactly my point though. He does. He's not the player that some seem to believe. He's an extremely poor rebounder and an extremely poor defender. You can't win with a big man who is like that.
You want me to shut up about Bargnani, maybe people have to stop making excuses for him and pumping him up as something he simply is not.
Hey, you really want me to shut up about him, get him traded off the team.




Reply With Quote